The Evangelical Crackup

New York Times: The Evangelical Crackup (Lengthy article but worth reading.)

Fox is not the only conservative Christian to feel the heat of those battles, even in — of all places — Wichita. Within three months of his departure, the two other most influential conservative Christian pastors in the city had left their pulpits as well. And in the silence left by their voices, a new generation of pastors distinctly suspicious of the Republican Party — some as likely to lean left as right — is beginning to speak up.

Just three years ago, the leaders of the conservative Christian political movement could almost see the Promised Land. White evangelical Protestants looked like perhaps the most potent voting bloc in America. They turned out for President George W. Bush in record numbers, supporting him for re-election by a ratio of four to one. Republican strategists predicted that religious traditionalists would help bring about an era of dominance for their party. Spokesmen for the Christian conservative movement warned of the wrath of “values voters.” James C. Dobson, the founder of Focus on the Family, was poised to play kingmaker in 2008, at least in the Republican primary. And thanks to President Bush, the Supreme Court appeared just one vote away from answering the prayers of evangelical activists by overturning Roe v. Wade.

Today the movement shows signs of coming apart beneath its leaders. It is not merely that none of the 2008 Republican front-runners come close to measuring up to President Bush in the eyes of the evangelical faithful, although it would be hard to find a cast of characters more ill fit for those shoes: a lapsed-Catholic big-city mayor; a Massachusetts Mormon; a church-skipping Hollywood character actor; and a political renegade known for crossing swords with the Rev. Pat Robertson and the Rev. Jerry Falwell. Nor is the problem simply that the Democratic presidential front-runners — Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton, Senator Barack Obama and former Senator John Edwards — sound like a bunch of tent-revival Bible thumpers compared with the Republicans.


Comments

3 responses to “The Evangelical Crackup”

  1. That was a long but very interesting read. It does look as though, again, there is little middle ground and that one more painful and splitty polarization is on the horizon.
    I just hope and pray that we will all see sense and end up putting our Lord and the fellowship of His body first.

  2. It remains to be seen in my mind what is actually going on here. I think some of this just those who are no hard right being more vocal. Some is actual change in perspective. I will say this, however, I think American Evangelicals are notorious for joining populist swings in the pendulum instead of being grounded in a solid narrative of what God is doing in the world. I fear some of that is at work.
    It does make unity in the body a challenge.

  3. I guess that there is still time. Positions seem to be developing but have not hardened into definite standoffs yet. A lot of the question will be whether the generational change is being resisted by a significant minority of the evangelical youth – in which case it will make it easier for a fight to develop? It’s worth keeping an eye on!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Kruse Kronicle

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading