The Suprising Impact of China’s “Sweatshops”

Oregon Live: Chinese factory workers cash in sweat for prosperity

WUHU, China — Years after activists accused Nike and other Western brands of running Third World sweatshops, the issue has taken a surprising turn.

The path of discovery winds from coastal factory floors far into China's interior, past women knee-deep in streams pounding laundry. It continues down a dusty village lane to a startling sight: arrays of gleaming three-story houses with balconies, balustrades and even Greek columns rising from rice paddies.

It turns out that factory workers — not the activists labeled "preachy" by one expert, and not the Nike executives so wounded by criticism — get the last laugh. Villagers who "went out," as Chinese say, for what critics described as dead-end manufacturing jobs are sending money back and returning with savings, building houses and starting businesses.

Workers who stitched shoes for Nike Inc. and apparel for Columbia Sportswear Co., both based near Beaverton, are fueling a wave of prosperity in rural China. The boom has a solid feel, with villagers paying cash for houses.

"No one would take out a mortgage to build a house," said Wang Jianguo, 37, who returned after a factory injury in a distant province to the area near Wuhu, west of Shanghai. "You wouldn't feel secure living in a house you didn't own."

In the end, market forces and ambition, not activism or corporate initiatives, pushed up wages and improved working conditions. The forces originally unleashed by the late Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping still drive China's economy, producing a manufacturing labor shortage and giving villagers viable choices beyond factory work. …

This process of economic development is one of the hardest ones for me to watch. It is hard to justify the horrible conditions under which some work. And yet I keep reminding myself that these people chose this work because it was a better option than they have been experiencing. Maybe that speaks more to my ignorance of their daily existence than it does to the inhumanities (by American standards) of these workplaces.

Below is a video that goes along with the article. Below it is another video that I think highlights the ambivalent feelings I have watching globalization at work.

China's rural boom


Comments

3 responses to “The Suprising Impact of China’s “Sweatshops””

  1. Thanks for posting this, Michael. It is very important for folks to see things from the workers’ perspective … and their choice to work in conditions “below” ours does derive from the true lack of opportunities. They make the best of their circumstances.
    …and most of our poor would be shocked at how the poor in the Majority World live. Just sayin’

  2. I am wrestling through the same set of questions as you are here with how work conditions and pay ought to be just… while also acknowledging that some of these options are better than, say… prostitution or the like. Thanks for the post! If your interested, feel free to check out a post series I did in a similar vein of thought: http://groansfromwithin.com/2010/02/20/is-ethical-buying-the-new-legalism-part-1/

  3. Kurt, thanks for stopping by. What a great post!. Thanks for sharing it.

Leave a Reply to Kurt WillemsCancel reply

Discover more from Kruse Kronicle

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading